This is definitely NOT us (ruminations on parenting and other regrets)

FB_IMG_1553095371311

FB_IMG_1553095220098

I used to take pride in my parenting skills. Not that I did everything right. God knows no one does. Maybe pride isn’t the right word. But I tried to approach parenting as a “challenge and an opportunity” as my late husband often said. I tried to be fair, treating each of my children as the distinctly different people they are, yet with consistency. I didn’t rely on parenting self-help books or put too much credence in psychological theorizing. Rather, I sought wisdom from the Bible and from others I felt had endured some of the same challenges I faced, first as a single parent and subsequently as a “blended” family. My husband and I were careful to present a unified front, and tried not to react in anger. Although I know there were areas where my decisions erred on the side of caution I considered myself blessed to have three wonderful children who are high functioning adults. All good right?

Then came “This is Us”.

Yes, a television show has shattered any illusions I had about being mother of the year, or even a runner-up. Without giving away any spoilers to those who may not be current on this season, there was the episode where Rebecca, the perfect mom, sat watching old family movies, crying over the memories. And I cried right along with her. My tears, however, were because I realized that I didn’t HAVE any movies or videos of my children or family. Not one. First major motherhood failure.

And then there was the episode when Jack, the perfect dad, was going through a tough time and was not his usual charming self. Of course, before the episode’s end he realized his foul mood was affecting his children, and he allowed a free for all in the form of a confetti fight break out, without concern of the mess or the cleanup that might ensue. And perfect mom Rebecca’s only response was to smile and say “I’m not cleaning it up “. No yelling, no time outs, no drama.

Major motherhood failure number two. I cried again, this time because I realized that I didn’t play enough, didn’t allow my children to just let loose once in a while without worrying about the mess. I mean, I told them that Play Dough was an outside toy because I didn’t want it stuck in the carpet! What good mother does that?

And of course there is the ever present theme that runs through the entire show – the idea that, no matter what, they have each other’s back. Even if they don’t share the same life goals, or career paths; even if they live on opposite coasts; even if they are alternately (or simultaneously) struggling with addiction, a moral crisis, an emotional breakdown; even if they aren’t biological siblings in the true sense of the word. No matter what, these three adult children of the seemingly perfect parents are always there for each other.

Which is the one thing I hope I have successfully taught to my own three children. That family is it. Whether or not you like the same music, whether you are “Marvel” or “DC”, no matter where you live or who you marry (or don’t marry). Family is where you get to practice unconditional love, the place where you should feel safe to be yourself. And where you let others do the same.

I have encouraged my children many times to stay connected to each other, to maintain the relationships that are the most precious. Without trying to sound morbid, I have told them that there will come a time when their father and I won’t be here to plan gatherings and foster conversations. All they will have is each other.

So on that count, I seem to be on the same page as the perfect parents Bec and Jack.

In a recent episode the Big Three, as they refer to their collective selves, were at a high school graduation party, discussing their futures and what their relationship would be like. Randall wisely said “As long as we stay in each other’s lives we’ll be okay.” Amen to that Randall.

So we may not have any movies (a ton of pictures though), and maybe my children were stifled by not experiencing enough uninhibited play times. Maybe you won’t see me on the cover of Parent magazine, and you can rest assured there are things I wish I had done differently. But I take comfort in knowing that as long as they stay in each other’s lives, they’ll be okay. Thanks “This is Us”.

One thought on “This is definitely NOT us (ruminations on parenting and other regrets)

  1. Wow. That is the mark of a great show if it makes you connect and reflect in that manner. I hope that it doesn’t make u too sad though! And it is NEVER TOO LATE TO PLAY! Omg girl. Grab that confetti now and get to it! (Then tell them you’re not cleaning it up 😉

    Like

Leave a reply to W.D. Herstun Cancel reply